CLAMP Score Sheet for Biogeochemical Model Evaluation

Metric Metric
components
Observations &
comparison protocol
Model
FCN
Model
FCNcropNTsupln
Score (points)
Full FCN FCNcropNTsupln
NPP EMDI NPP
observations
Class_A_table table
scatter_plot
table
scatter_plot
2.5 1.65 1.69
Class_B_table table
scatter_plot
table
scatter_plot
2.5 2.07 2.08
EMDI NPP
normalized by PPT
Class_A_histogram Class_A_histogram Class_A_histogram 2.5 2.03 2.10
Class_B_histogram Class_B_histogram Class_B_histogram 2.5 2.03 2.12
Correlation with MODIS obs. global_map model_map
model_vs_obs
model_map
model_vs_obs
5 3.41 3.39
Correlation with MODIS-zonal mean zonal_mean_obs zonal_mean
model_vs_obs_plot
zonal_mean
model_vs_obs_plot
5 3.05 3.13
LAI MODIS Mean land_class_obs
land_class_model
global_map
model_vs_obs_table
global_map
model_vs_obs
model_vs_obs_table
global_map
model_vs_obs
5 4.34 4.39
MODIS Maximum global_map global_map
model_vs_obs
global_map
model_vs_obs
5 4.26 4.27
MODIS Phase global_map global_map
model_vs_obs
global_map
model_vs_obs
5 4.00 3.99
CO2
Seasonal
Cycle
Comparison with NOAA observations
phase and amplitude
-- -- -- 20 -- --
Carbon
Stocks
Aboveground live biomass
in South America
obs_amazon model_amazon
model_vs_obs
amazon_map
model_vs_obs
5 2.78 2.78
Aboveground live
biomass
within Amazon Basin
(sum within Legal Amazon)
mask
obs_masked
69.37 (Pg C)
model_masked
model_vs_obs
109.28 (Pg C)
model_masked
model_vs_obs
109.49 (Pg C)
5 3.28 3.28
Energy and
C Fluxes
from Fluxnet
NEE line_plot model_vs_obs model_vs_obs 5 2.24 2.22
Net radiation 5 3.59 3.58
Latent heat 5 3.62 3.67
Sensible heat 5 3.58 3.61
Energy and
C Fluxes
from Ameriflux
NEE line_plot model_vs_obs
timeseries_plot
model_vs_obs
timeseries_plot
1 0.38 0.41
Shortwave Incoming 1 0.90 0.89
Latent heat 1 0.73 0.74
Sensible heat 1 0.72 0.71
GPP 1 0.55 0.56
ER 1 0.69 0.70
Transient Dynamics Beta factor for NPP Stimulation from elevated CO2 -- FACE_Site_comparison
biome_table
FACE_Site_comparison
biome_table
3 0.00 0.00
Turnover times and pool sizes -- Leaf
Wood
Fine_Root
Litter
Coarse_Woody_Debris
Soil
Leaf
Wood
Fine_Root
Litter
Coarse_Woody_Debris
Soil
3 -- --
Carbon Sinks
(1990-2004)
-- biome_mean
biome_total
biome_mean
biome_total
2 -- --
Fire Variability -- global_spatial_comparison
temporal_dynamics_(1997-2004)
-- 2 M_fire --
Total 100 49.92 50.32